Market-making is a cornerstone of financial markets, ensuring liquidity and efficient price discovery. While the premise is universal across sectors, market-making in cryptocurrency differs significantly from its counterpart in traditional finance. The volatility, technological infrastructure, and regulatory environment of the cryptocurrency field present unique difficulties and opportunities for crypto market-makers.
Liquidity in an Immature Market
Unlike traditional financial markets, where assets like stocks, bonds, and forex have decades of institutional history and liquidity, the crypto market is relatively new. Crypto market-makers operate in an ecosystem where liquidity is often fragmented across various exchanges and trading pairs. In traditional finance, exchanges like the London Stock Exchange or NYSE centralise trading for major instruments, offering robust liquidity pools. In contrast, market-making in crypto often involves managing liquidity across multiple decentralised and centralised exchanges with varying degrees of volume and stability. This fragmentation requires advanced technology and active strategies to prevent slippage and maintain tight spreads.
Technology-Driven Operations
Market-making in cryptocurrency is deeply reliant on technology, more so than in traditional finance. While high-frequency trading (HFT) systems exist in both sectors, crypto market-makers must adapt to the rapidly evolving landscape of blockchain networks, smart contracts, and decentralised finance (DeFi) protocols. The APIs of crypto exchanges are less standardised, and system reliability can vary significantly across platforms. This instance means that crypto market-makers often build proprietary systems to handle multiple exchange integrations, manage risk in real-time, and adjust strategies dynamically based on market conditions. Market-makers in traditional finance typically work within established frameworks with long-standing relationships and tested infrastructure, allowing for more predictable operations.
Risk Management in an Unstable Market
Volatility in crypto markets is significantly higher than in traditional finance. While a 2% daily move in major equities may be considered notable, the crypto market regularly sees double-digit percentage swings within hours. This exposes crypto market-makers to higher inventory risks and demands more aggressive risk management strategies. They must account for sudden regulatory announcements, security breaches, or token-specific issues like smart contract exploits. Market-makers in traditional finance can often rely on more stable regulatory environments and established risk metrics. In crypto, managing the risks of being long or short in a rapidly moving and speculative market is far more challenging, especially for illiquid tokens.
ALSO READ: Retainer vs Options Model for Market-Making
Regulatory Uncertainty
Cryptocurrency market-makers also navigate a far less defined regulatory landscape. In traditional finance, market-making activities are well-regulated under established legal frameworks. Market-makers are subject to compliance requirements, licensing, and oversight from financial authorities like the FCA or SEC. In contrast, the regulatory environment for market-making in crypto remains unclear in many jurisdictions. Some countries classify market-makers as brokers or dealers, while others impose no specific rules. This ambiguity creates operational challenges and legal risks that traditional market-makers rarely face. Cryptocurrency market-makers must be adaptable, keeping up with emerging regulations while ensuring compliance across multiple jurisdictions.
Market Access and Global Reach
Traditional market-makers typically operate within defined national or regional markets, adhering to specific regulatory frameworks. Market-making in crypto is inherently global. Cryptocurrency market-makers can operate across exchanges worldwide, with few barriers to entry in terms of jurisdiction. This global reach allows market-makers to capitalise on arbitrage opportunities across exchanges in different countries and currencies. However, it also exposes them to cross-border regulatory conflicts, taxation complexities, and compliance burdens that are less prominent in traditional finance.
In summary, while the core role of providing liquidity and facilitating trading remains the same, the tools, risks, and strategies of market-making in crypto are distinct from those in traditional finance. Cryptocurrency market-makers must handle increased volatility, fragmented liquidity, technical complexity, and regulatory uncertainty, making it a more dynamic but riskier profession than its traditional finance rivals.
Visit Caladan and let us provide you with strategic guidance and tailored liquidity solutions in the ever-evolving crypto space.
